The volunteer army

From: Bill Reed
Sent: Thursday, June 23, 2011 11:31 AM
To: Criss, Susan
Subject: FW: Needing volunteers for Galveston County "No-Refusal" weekend for July 1,2,3 @ Dickinson Police Department: 8pm-4am 

Judge: are you available? So far Lonnie and Ellisor are in. Grady is out of town. thanks, BR

*****

From: Bill Reed
Sent: Wednesday, August 24, 2011 9:59 AM
To: Ellisor, John; Cox, Lonnie; Mallia, Wayne; Criss, Susan; Dupuy, Christopher; Grady, John
Subject: looking for volunteers for No Refusal Weekend for Labor Day: 9/2/11-9/4/11 

Any takers? Thanks, BR

Looking for volunteers?

Or, are you looking for judges who will blindly sign a warrant authorizing a forcible blood draw based on a fill-in-the-blank affidavit? Are you looking for judges who buy into your notion that a person accused of driving while intoxicated has fewer rights (or at least less-important rights) than a person charged with any other offense? Are you looking for judges who agree that we should do whatever it takes to coerce people into pleading guilty to DWI?

You see the DA's Office is hand-picking its judges. They're going back to the judges who have signed, without question, warrants in the past and who are more than willing to continue to do so. The last thing the state wants is a judge who might just question this practice.

No. The deck must be stacked against the citizen accused. Even if we have to make an absolute mockery out of a document we all took an oath to uphold.

What, you think these judges are actually reading these affidavits and asking themselves if the officer has but forward enough facts to support his arrest decision?

From: Chris Paschenko
Date: Friday, Dec 31, 2010 12:01 pm
Subject: DWI arrests
To: Judge Susan Criss 

We[re] you working and in what capacity when [L.B.] and [T.R.] were arrested? I'm told it was DWI. Also seeking on the record comment.
Thanks.
Chris

*****

From: judgecriss
To: Chris Paschenko
Sent: Fri, Dec 31, 2010 12:39 pm
Subject: Re: DWI arrests
I was the judge at the station last night there to sign warrants worked 8pm to 4 am. Rules do not allow me to comment on the cases. Signed LB blood search warrant. Other waived need for warrant.

What else needs to be said about the mechanics of a No Refusal Weekend. There you have a judge telling a reporter that she was at the station "to sign warrants."

Not to review them. But to sign them.

Sadly, most folks don't care. They see nothing wrong with jabbing needles in someone's arm because you think they might have been intoxicated. Hey, we're out there keeping you safe. And these are the same folks who are more than willing to suffer any indignity at the hand of TSA employees just so they can board a plane. Hey, gotta keep us safe from terrorists.

Maybe we're just so self-absorbed that we simply don't care if the government is intruding on someone's rights - so long as we're not the one being trampled upon. As long as it's then that the government is after it's okay. The only problem is that at some point there will be no more them to protect you from the coercive power of the state. And, by then, it will be too late.

Filling in the blanks

June 25, 2008 

"The Galveston County Criminal District Attorney's Office is coordinating another no-refusal weekend for Friday July 3 and Saturday July 4, 2009. Dickinson Police Department has graciously agreed to host the event again this year. Judge Lonnie Cox will be our judge for Friday night and Judge John Ellisor will perform those duties on Saturday night. The hours of operation will be from 8:30 PM on July 3, 2009 until 4:30 AM on July 4, 2009 and against at 8:30 PM on July 4, 2009 until 4:30 AM on July 5, 2009... 

I have attached the search warrants and affidavits for search warrants. The search warrant returns can be done immediately after the blood draw is performed." 

-- Galveston County Assistant District Attorney Joel H. Bennett

That's right. We've got your search warrant and affidavits right here. They're ready for you to fill in the blanks and type 'em up. No need to make an officer actually recite the facts in a case that gave rise to his belief that the driver was intoxicated at the time of driving. Nope. Just plug in your name and the motorist's name and we're in business.

I understand prosecutors and police wanting fill-in-the-blank affidavits, it allows officers to spend more time on the streets harassing citizens policing. But what's the judge's excuse for signing a warrant authorizing a forcible blood draw based on a fill-in-the-blank affidavit. Somehow I'm not thinking that would cut it if a district judge were trying to decide whether or not to allow the police to enter someone's house to search for evidence of a crime. In fact, I know it wouldn't. But, then again, we're only talking about a misdemeanor. What's the big freaking deal, anyway?

I mean, all we're asking to do is to perform an invasive procedure on a motorist based on our hunch that she might be intoxicated and the fact that she exercised her right to refuse a breath test. Well, that and we can strap her down if she resists. But, c'mon, why all the hoops?

January 2, 2011 

"The morning of December 30, 2010, Fox 26 News began to air footage preparing the public for our initiative, as I addressed the public and presented a "warning and awareness" that our intentions were to increase public safety by removing DWI offenders from our roadways on Galveston Island and a Zero Tolerance No Refusal approach method would be in effect to combat this problem... 

"With the assistance of the following agencies the effort was a success:

• UTMB

• Galveston County District Attorney's Office

• District Judge Lonnie Cox

• District Judge Susan Criss

• County Judge John Grady

• The Galveston Police Department Command Staff

• The Galveston Daily News

• Fox 26 News

• Texas Highway Patrol

"Over the last month I have been in correspondence with the listed agencies and the initiative was proven a success. 

-- Chad Powers, Galveston Police Department

What could possibly be more clear as to the role of the judges in these assaults on the Fourth Amendment? It's not the job of a judge to assist in the arrest and/or prosecution of anyone. It is the role of the judge to sit as a neutral arbiter in a legal proceeding. When the police begin thanking judges for assisting in their initiatives, it's time to start questioning the role of those judges in our criminal (in)justice system.

Since most of these DWI cases will be filed in county court as misdemeanors, two of the judges (Grady and Dupuy) reviewing warrants on suppression hearings are two of the judges who volunteered to approve these fill-in-the-blank form affidavits. And just how do you think those rulings are going to go?

Slowly but surely the judiciary is being subsumed into the trial division of the district attorney's office. Maybe it makes for great copy during campaign season. Maybe the voters like it. You know, the voters who either blindly mark R or D on their ballot or think that judicial candidates should sound like they're running for sheriff or DA.

Should I bring a pen along?

Last August I wrote about documents I received through an open records request for documents related to No Refusal Weekends in Harris County. See here, here, here and here.

Today it's time to take a trip down the Gulf Freeway to the island to what Galveston County officials have been up to when it comes to making a mockery out of the Fourth Amendment.

June 27, 2011 - 

"Special Crimes Prosecutor Bill Reed has coordinated preparations for this event, which will take place in Galveston County this Friday, Saturday and Sunday nights from 8 pm through 4 am at the Dickinson Police Department. (Special thanks go to Chief Morales for his hospitality.) Bill has enlisted the cooperation of Judges Lonnie Cox, John Ellisor and Christopher Dupuy to approve and sign the blood search warrants, as well as nurses who will be present and ready to make the blood draws." 

-- Galveston County District Attorney Jack Roady (group e-mail)

The DA's Office has "enlisted the cooperation" of judges to "approve and sign" search warrants authorizing blood draws. As I have stated many times before, if the state is "enlisting" judges to participate in this spectacle, the deck is already stacked against anyone accused of driving while intoxicated. And, yes, that Christopher Dupuy.

Hmmm... how might that conversation go?

Prosecutor: "Judge, I was wondering if you'd like to volunteer to approve and sign search warrants for blood draws during our No Refusal Weekend?"

Judge: "Ordering a blood draw on a misdemeanor case? That's insane."


Prosecutor: "I'll take that as a no. Next!"

August 31, 2011 - 

"Special Crimes Prosecutor Bill Reed has coordinated for this event, which will take place in Galveston County this Friday, Saturday and Sunday nights from 11 pm through 4 am at the Dickinson Police Department. Bill has enlisted the cooperation of Judges John Ellisor, Christopher Dupuy and John Grady to approve and sign the blood search warrants, as well as nurses who will be present and ready to make the blood draws." 

-- Galveston County District Attorney Jack Roady (group e-mail)

Please note, no one is talking about reviewing warrant applications. The judges are there to approve the warrants and subject motorists to an intrusive procedure. This is limited government? Oh, now I understand, they were talking about limiting the authority the judiciary has over the police, not the authority of the state over the individual. That makes so much more sense now.

An application for a search warrant should be reviewed by a neutral and detached magistrate. Once a judge accepts the pitch from the DA to be a part of the team for a No Refusal Weekend, that judge loses any claim to being detached. Either he was asked to participate or he volunteered - either way, the judge is far from neutral.

And despite "fill in the blank" warrant applications that are long on conclusions and woefully short on facts, these "neutral and detached" judges are more than happy to take pen to paper to authorize the shredding of the last remnants of the constitution.